jump to navigation

Weekly “cohort” gathering June 16, 2009

Posted by Nate in Uncategorized.
add a comment

If you are interested in joining some of the local pastors and community leaders for support and dialog about what it means to lead in the way of Jesus, we meet at 9:30 every Wednesday morning at Lone Pine coffee (tin pan alley) and then go upstairs to Poethouse for an hour and a half.

Ordination: A Viral Firestorm (repost from www.gregbolt.com) May 19, 2009

Posted by ggbolt16 in Uncategorized.
Tags: , , , , , , ,
add a comment

I thought this might be a good topic for debate or at least I would like to get some other opinions on the topic of ordination.

UPDATE: Before I posted this I wanted to make sure I got my facts straight (funny thing…I didn’t get it right and am now more enlightened…who knew?). So I (gasp!) asked Adam to check out the post and see if I misrepresented him in any way, shockingly I did get some things out of whack and (honoring my statement about correction) I changed them, but also leaving in the original so you can see where I was misled.  I even went as far as to *embarrassingly* misspell the name of someone I call “a friend, colleague, fellow ultimate frisbee player, and guest in my home” TWICE!  Adam, a thousand apologies.

sequoia-forest-fire-505503-swLast Friday someone I would consider a friend, colleague, fellow ultimate frisbee player, and guest in my home, Adam Walker Cleaveland Cleveland, posted about his latest frustration with his ordination process.  Since Adam’s post countless other posts and enumerable comments have being flying through the internet with everyone (including me, and me) doling out their opinion on “sinful institutions”, “deconstructionalists”, “emergents”, etc., etc.

I figured I would help out those of you who read my blog (Hi Mom!) and give you a one stop shop to find posts that I think are relevant, thoughtful, and meaningful in this debate: (There is even a back and forth between “de-facto emergent church bishop” Tony Jones and an old friend of his, Rev. John A. D’Elia.)  I will try to put them in some reasonable order:

The match that started the blaze: When an M.Div. from Princeton isn’t Enough… by Adam Walker Cleaveland Cleveland

The fuel that fed it: Let’s Ordain Adam by Tony Jones (including Tony’s “ironic” online petition to ordain Adam)

The forest that began to smolder around the blaze:

The brush fire that caught along the way: (i.e. the “debate” between Tony and John)

I am sure there are many other blogs, comments, tweets, emails, snail mails, etc. out there but I think you get the idea.

I almost forgot to add my own little nuggets of wisdom…from what I know about Adam’s situation (I am very welcome to correction if I am telling tales outside of school) is that Adam is serving in United Methodist Church in Livermore, CA as the youth director/minister/pastor/whatever, Minister for Youth and Young Adults.  He completed all of the requirements for Kendall Presbytery to certify him ready to seek a call (MDiv, ordination exams, CPE, etc.) he then hit a snag when he asked a friend of his to preach at his ordination service.  Kendall Presbytery CPM balked at his selection and he was then not able to stand for examination in front of the presbytery “after a 4-hr meeting with CPM, they decided the best possible situation would be to transfer me  (Adam) down to SF presbytery.” Adam then decided to went along with the transfer of his membership to San Francisco Presbytery (transferring presbyteries in the middle of your process is a notoriously bad idea, and Adam knew that).  San Francisco Presbytery then told Adam that he need to take a lot more classes before he could be examined.  Knowing the process of ordination in the PC(USA), I am surprised that Adam did what he did, but it’s his process and who am I to judge his decisions that I am sure were prayerfully considered and discerned.

Here’s I think a very important point that no one is talking about (or at least no one I’ve read)…Adam is currently working in a NON-ORDAINED position at a UNITED METHODIST church, not a Presbyterian church.  If Kendall Presbytery had ORDAINED Adam it would have been to “service to the larger church” (think missionaries, professors, publishers, camp directors).  The ordination as a minister of Word and Sacrament in a traditional church/pulpit is hard enough, but when you add extenuating circumstances on top of that it makes it that much more difficult.  The PC (USA) holds ordination in very high regard so it makes since that not just anybody is ordained to anything. (That is not a statement on Adam’s gifts or skills. Adam is a great guy with lots of things to offer.  I’m just saying it was always going to be more difficult than your “standard” ordination.)

As the polity goes (strictly speaking for better or for worse), Kendall Presbytery was doing Adam a favor was going out of its way to even consider him for ordination.  The fact that Adam was theologically on the fringe of the presbytery that he was under care of and the fact that most people don’t like it when you air their dirty laundry business, this was always going to be difficult.

Another thing to keep in mind…while there are many people like Adam, Tony, and, for that matter, me that value transparency, the PC (USA) is a very diverse denomination (age, economics, theology, politics) and there are many others that don’t understand why anyone would post “everything”, so it stands to reason that keeping your opinions to yourself or to a small group of friends and confidants would be the wiser course of action.  Maybe I should be listening to my own advice…who knows?

I say all of this to say that Adam is a good guy and a influential voice and I hope and pray that through this Adam will learn and grow in his pastoral identity and his ministry.  I also hope that the we all can learn and listen for God’s will and in our lives.

Just for the record…the service of ordination that includes the laying on of hands is for me one of the most powerful “occasional” services that I have seen in the PC (USA) (services I’ve seen include my dad (elder), my mom (elder), my wife (minister of Word and Sacrament)).  I also believe that when I sit in the pew watching (I am not ordained…yet…fingers crossed) the other ordained persons lay hands on the newly ordained I find hope and joy.  It will be a glorious day for me when I can kneel in front of those that have guided me through the ordination process and my faith life as they can affirm my call.

Blessings,

Greg

[Photograph by Raymond Gehman]

You May Have Heard It Said…But February 26, 2009

Posted by ggbolt16 in Uncategorized.
Tags: , , ,
add a comment

Now after many moons of waiting I am finally posting the video of the presentation that I did at Ignite Bend #1 on February 12. This was an opportunity to reclaim Christianity from the media and the talking heads we see on TV (or at least that is what my wife said). The title of my presentation was “You May Have Heard It Said…But“. Apparently, these events that have happened in several other cities and have attracted mostly techie presenters. I appreciate this group allowing me to crash their party.

I have received nothing but postitive response from people who saw this presentation, both live and on the live stream (which is still up if you want to see all eight presentations) over the interwebs. I thought I would put it here and see what other people thought. From this interaction I been able to make connections with some great folk in and around Bend, both in the context of ministry and on a personal level. I hope that I am able to continue my involment with these type of events and I hope that my relationships in the community will continue to grow. Another wonderful thing that happened while preparing for this event was that I sent out a call to help me with the language that I should use which garnered an overwhelming response that I blogged about here.

I would be remiss if I did not mention Matt and JoAnn at Pinnacle Media for there wonderful set up of all things media. (He also put together a DVD of this event that he is letting me rip and edit so I can post it here and here.) I would also like to give a shout out to Colin, Jen, Sarah, Julie, Melinda, Cassondra, Ryan, Owen and all of the other folks who made this happen. I also would like to give a plug for twitter because if it weren’t for that wonderful new medium I would have never known about this super awesome event.

Blessings,

Greg

PS There will be another Ignite Bend in May, that is already in the works and one scheduled for some time in September. Check it out it was fun.

Presbymergent February 17, 2009

Posted by bobpearson in Uncategorized.
add a comment

Hi guys,

I am spending this week in Louisvile with 35 or so Emerging types all of the Presbyterian pursuasion.  I was wondering, what questions or comments would you make to this group?  What would you like to know about the people who cling to a denominational structure who are also very committed to the emerging church dialog and process?  What would you like to see a group like this take on as goals and tasks that would further the Kingdom in our neck of Christianity?  This will be a very interactive, open-space type of gathering so any idea or topic is open to discussion.

Bob

Ignite Bend February 8, 2009

Posted by bobpearson in Uncategorized.
add a comment

This Thursday, Feb 12 at 7:00 at the Loft/Poet House off Minnesota Ave, Ignite Bend will have its first event. There will be eight presentations of 5 minutes each with 20 slides that are on a 15 second timer each. This format was created in Seattle and has been used around the world. The reason this is being posted to this blog is that Greg Bolt will be one of the presenters and he is using the title “You have heard it said”. This will contrast the view of some people of a conservative, absolute truth based, judgmental Christianity with a more open, inviting loving and questioning faith. Tickets are limited, but will be available at the door if space permits.

Also, on Monday, Feb 9th, at 7:00 pm we will be gathering at the Bend Brewery for the monthly Pub talk. Music will be provided by the Gladden brothers. If you want to engage with other postmodern thinkers in an open, non-judgmental conversation then this is the place to be on Monday. Great Beer and food are available for purchase.

Emergent Village Restructuring Conversation: Hitler and the Emergent Village November 27, 2008

Posted by ggbolt16 in Uncategorized.
6 comments

I think this is interesting, however using Hitler and Nazi Germany as spoof may be a delicate line, this seems to toe it nicely.

I wonder about your thoughts on this video.

Blessings and Happy Thanksgiving,

Greg

Also, this might be a good place to look: Tall Skinny Kiwi, Emergent Village, whatever you do

Post-Modernism and the Death of the Western World November 26, 2008

Posted by bobpearson in Uncategorized.
1 comment so far

I was recently sent the article below.  Since many of us on this blog are both postmodern and spiritual and even committed followers of Jesus, I wanted to introduce this perspective into a discussion.  The author clearly has no use for any of postmodernism, and sees the loss of the greatest of western culture that is occurring in his view as the death of all humanity has achieved up to now.  This is a critique of postmodernism that is not about theology directly, but his view that it is totally a secular exercise begs the question at least.

Flame on…?

Bob

 

Post-Modernism and the Death of the Western World
 
POST- MODERNISM really isn’t a culture, but an anti-culture. It’s what people do in the absence of authentic culture…it is a downward spiral into the abyss. 
 
At the opposite end of the spectrum lies what I call “ORGANIC CULTURE.” Organic cultures are typified most importantly by a “chain of being.” In such cultures an individual sees himself as one link in a family that extends back through innumerable generations. Such an individual also looks to the future and adjusts his time preferences to account for the needs of future generations. Respect of one’s ancestors and concern for one’s descendants are thus wrapped together in a religious and culture milieu that is of profound importance in everyday life. 
 
The Western world, beginning with the French Revolution and culminating in WW I is now drowning in the cesspool of post-modernism. Our intellectual and cultural elites have long since abandoned whatever remnants of organic culture they may have had and now totally embrace this new, dysfunctional cultural World view. 
 
This is of importance for several reasons. In particular, like Alexis de Tocqueville, I don’t believe a system of self-government can exist in the absence of an ethical people. A society of self-indulgent, cosmopolitan vagabonds cannot maintain a free republic. Our system is, in fact, breaking down all around us. The post-modern worldview, and its attendant self-destructive contradictions, is causing much of the decay we are now experiencing.
 
Specifically, post-modernism suffers from three major flaws that are leading to its (and our) demise.
 
1. ETHICAL RELATIVISM
Perhaps the most important task of any civilization is to develop a single, coherent system of morality (and to transmit that system to its youth). A functioning society requires almost continual interaction between citizens. And that, in turn, requires a high level of trust. Without that trust, and without a common set of principles on which to base it, the entire system unravels.
 
Post-modernism is marked by extreme relativism, secularism, and multiculturalism. In fact, post-modernism prides itself in its disdain for any system of ethics, believing this disdain represents “liberation” from oppressive social structures. We can see the results of this philosophy all around us. Sexual (im)morality, a decline in standards of dress, language, and behavior and a political leadership based on lies and deception, are some examples. 
 
2. AUTO-GENOCIDE
Post-modern culture treats children as an expensive and peculiar hobby, something like a curious fashion statement. If children are seen as a mere fashion accessory or an emotional indulgence, then one will do just as well as two (and much better than three or four). This attitude reveals itself in the demographic statistics of all societies that have adopted post-modernism. Across the Western world there has been a catastrophic collapse in birthrates. Over the next few decades, parts of Europe may see their populations fall in half. 
 
Organic culture views children in a radically different fashion, which was summed up brilliantly by Oswald Spengler in his seminal The Hour of Decision:
A woman of [tribe] does not desire to be a “companion” or a “lover,” but a mother; and not the mother of one child, to serve as a toy and distraction, but of many: the instinct of a strong tribe speaks in the pride that large families inspire….A man wants stout sons who will perpetuate his name and his deeds beyond his death into the future and enhance them, just as he has done himself through feeling himself heir to the calling and works of his ancestors.
 
Since the West has adopted the post-modern world model, it has only two choices: It can throw off the yoke of post-modernism and reestablish an organic culture that is capable of reproducing itself, or it will be colonized and overrun by other, more prolific cultures.
 
3. THE DEATH OF THE SACRED.
Post-modernism is a materialist philosophy to its very core. By “materialist,” I don’t mean greedy (though Heaven knows there is plenty of that), but rather I refer to the Marxist sense of the term. Post-modernism is anti-spiritual. It recognizes nothing beyond the immediate, concrete world. It has no higher aspirations and provides no spiritual sustenance to its adherents. 
 
Despite these materialist assertions, mankind needs a “reverence for the sacred” to inspire him to loftier heights. One need only walk into the Sistine Chapel or enjoy a Bach requiem mass to see the results of an artist’s soul being touched by the divine. 
 
The increasingly ugly and vulgar creations of our contemporary artistic world are, on the other hand, more likely a manifestation of post-modernism’s degeneration to its ultimate endgame: Nihilism. 
 
CONCLUSION:
It is difficult for contemporary generations to even imagine what has been lost. One of the reasons I enjoy cinematic productions of Jane Austen novels is for precisely this reason. It is fascinating to see what Western culture actually looked like before the collapse and to see how the people thought and acted. I’m fascinated by their complex manners, their vibrant sense of right-and-wrong, and their organic connection to their history (in Sense and Sensibility, even the bad guy, a total cad, carries a copy of Shakespeare’s sonnets in his pocket). Western culture has been withering since the early 20th Century. Those of us born during or after the sixties social revolution have no living memory of even a vestigial remnant of Western culture, but rather have experienced only the degenerate post-modernism, drenched in stifling humanism, absurd universalism, and fatuous egalitarianism, that has dominated ever since. 
 
Post-modernism has led us down the primrose path to decadence. This system of decadence, however enticing and delectable it may sometimes be, is unsustainable. It cannot go on. It will ultimately end in bankruptcy, demographic implosion, or Road Warrior-style chaos. 
 
If one believes in Spengler’s view of civilization as akin to an organic life form, then the West cannot recover its earlier, more pristine self any more than a senior citizen can be reborn as an adolescent. In that case, the die is cast and we are finished. But if Spengler is wrong, then the possibility of a rebirth exists. Only time will tell. 
 
-Steven LaTulippe